yoga is turning me into an optimist….
so is the symposium.
…Back to Eryximachus’ speech. He is the most rational. I think he is most relevent speakers to our times. Whether he is driven by emotion or not is regardless, none of the actions of these speakers line up with their words. However, his words seem to imply that he is not driven by emotion but by a sort of reason that nicely fits into his view of life. He’s a specialist and filters everything through his understanding of the body, his understanding of how to fix and rid the body from afflictions. He has misunderstood his reason though. The problem is that he only has an understanding of a part. Socrates says he prefers his own condition of openness to the whole to an almost perfect clarity about a part bought at the expense of forgetting the whole.
We see the specialist’s imperialism all over the place, among economists, who interpret man totally in terms of the market, or anthropologists, who interpret everything totally in terms of culture, each peddling a competence that can interpret the whole from a perspectival nook that even the most superficial analysis would show is far too narrow.
It is interesting that though Eryximachus is utterly unerotic, he is wholly concerned with the body and not the soul. The body, which we typically equate with eroticism.
E never mentions intellectual pleasures; he knows only of bodily pleasures hence the Pandemian (lower) Eros is really his Eros and not the Uranian (higher) Eros. Because pleasure is a part of the Pandemian Eros, the doctor compromises with it, trying to box it into his compartmentalized life. He talks about the need for dissimilar things. To have harmony one needs to have opposites.
Then! he prescribes nature’s disordliness with the affliction of the Pandemian Eros. But that begs the question of why wouldn’t the storms, plagues, etc that happen by nature just be parts of the relations between opposites that constitute nature?
Is this all just a prescription for the things that inconvenience man?
the doctor represents man’s self-preservative instinct, which is essentially unerotic and inimical to wild, death-defying Eros.
3 years ago • 0 notes

